Amanda Seyfried

(Ann Lee)

Lewis Pullman

(William Lee)

Thomasin McKenzie

(Mary Partington / Narrator)

Matthew Beard

(James Whittaker)

Christopher Abbott

(Abraham Standerin)

Viola Prettejohn

(Nancy Lee)

David Cale

(John Hocknell)

Stacy Martin

(Jane Wardly)

Scott Handy

(James Wardley)

Jeremy Wheeler

(John Townley)

Tim Blake Nelson

(Pastor Reuben Wight)

Daniel Blumberg

(Deacon Talmadge Bishop)

Willem van der Vegt

(Ann's Father)

Millie-Rose Crossley

(Ann Lee (12 Yrs))

Scott Alexander Young

(Chief Magistrate Tideswell)

George Taylor

(George Whitefield)

Matti Boustedt

(Captain Smith)

Alexis Latham

(Mr. Cunningham)

Shannon Woodward

(Mrs. Cunningham)

Lark White

(Patsy)

Roy McCrerey

(Mr. Shattuck)

Natalie Shinnick

(Elizabeth Hale)

Francis McBurney

(Infirmary Guard)

Lukas Johne

(Jailer)

Owen Good

(Clergyman)

Laurent Winkler

(Builder)

Christina Leonardi

(Young Shaker Woman)